Internal Recruiter

ATL or Remote l Application Deadline: May 3rd

Do your most impactful work here.

We have built an all-star team of skilled, passionate people. We look for a unique blend of insane talent & incredible humility. But we need your help to find twice as many people as we currently have! We need a strong, experienced internal recruiter.

New Story is on a mission to build a system by which 1,000,000 million people enter safe homes. This has never been done before quite like this. It will require the best and brightest minds, which is why we need someone to help us find them.

The work we do is challenging. It requires creativity, thoughtfulness, and resilience. The level of need we witness can be heartbreaking, but it is empowering to know we are taking action to fix the problem. This work matters and it relies on a great team to get it done.

We are looking for somebody with a high standard of excellence and a proven track record of building high performing teams. We hire roles for fundraisers, operations, software engineering, and much more.

Our ideal candidate for this role needs to be comfortable adjusting to changing needs of a growing business. Roles and requirements often evolve real-time, requiring expectations or needs to shift. We have a sense of urgency around our mission and prefer a default to action.


  • Find and attract the most qualified applicants for open roles.
  • Increasing the diversity of qualified applicants.
  • Reviewing and qualifying applicants before initiating further interview process.
  • Running the hiring process (alongside the hiring mangers) and providing a remarkable experience for applicants (both qualified and disqualified).
  • Collaborate with our hiring managers to create job descriptions and interview flows for new roles.
  • Source top-level talent from diverse online resources
  • Communicate with candidates throughout the interview process in a way that is warm, friendly and professional.
  • Track candidates in our Applicant Tracking System.
  • Manage scheduling and logistics throughout the entire interview cycle.
  • Answer candidates’ questions and provide interview feedback, when appropriate.
  • Interview candidates during initial stages
  • Report to hiring managers on statuses of open positions
  • Determine qualification criteria for each position


  • Experience running hiring process for 6-8 roles simultaneously.
  • Experience increasing the volume of candidates applying to roles.
  • Comfortable operating within medium-high ambiguity.
  • Excellent verbal and written communication skills
  • Experience with different selection processes, such as reference checks and phone interviews
  • Strong decision making skills
  • Familiar with applicant tracking systems
  • Fluency in Spanish is a plus


You love a challenge.

You are resourceful and creative to find solutions. Big goals don’t scare you – they inspire you.

You have a team ethos and love working with people.

You thrive in a creative, inventive, fast-paced startup environment, with people who are passionate about their work and mission. You’re excited to work cross-functionally with other departments and enjoy bringing people together to achieve a goal. People enjoy working with you because they know they can trust you.


You’re self-motivated.

You see something that can be improved, and you don’t wait to fix it. You have a strong desire to make New Story a world-class organization.


This opportunity is flexible on location with a slight preference for candidates based in Atlanta.

Our Culture

Culture is #1 for us. We invest significant time, focus, and resources to building the best environment possible. Why? Over the course of the year we spend a large chunk of our time at work. So at New Story, we want our team to find fulfillment, autonomy, mastery, and joy at work. A workplace where you can bring your whole self.

At New Story, you can expect to find a culture that reflects our values:

  • Humble Pursuit of Excellence. A combination of personal humility and intense professional will.
  • Express Gratitude and Empathy. How would you like to be treated? That’s how we strive to treat others. Always go above and beyond to do for others what you’d like them to do for you.
  • Improve Through Learning and Feedback. Learn why something worked or didn’t work, then implement the learning into future actions.
  • Team of Founders. An extreme ownership mindset where you see a problem, take action, and go above and beyond to help the team.
  • Think Big, Breakdown, and Execute. Set big measurable goals, formulate a plan, then execute the plan with relentless focus.
  • Simplify. Do more with less. This applies to everything: marketing, design, team meetings, writing, operations, and beyond.
Our Benefits

You’ll find our benefits are aimed at supporting a full and healthy lifestyle in all areas of life.

  • Full Healthcare. We believe in thriving communities and that starts with our team being happy and healthy. We offer a generous health insurance, dental, and vision care package alongside a monthly fitness stipend, so you can invest in your own wellness and health.
  • Unlimited Vacation after the 1st Year. We believe you should have a flexible schedule that makes space for family, wellness, and fun. For the first 12 months, you’ll have 12 days PTO and paid holidays. After that year, you can enjoy an unlimited vacation policy.
  • Work-from-home Flexibility. Due to COVID-19, we are completely remote at the moment. On a normal year, we have a flexible work from home policy.
  • 401k Investment Plan. New Story offers a 401k investment plan so you’re saving money for the long-term.
  • Trip to the Field. It’s amazing to meet the families we help and see the homes up close and personal. You’ll get to visit the work first hand in either Mexico, Haiti, or El Salvador.
  • Commuter Benefits. We’re grateful for all the time and energy each team member puts into getting to work every day. For some, getting to work takes additional time and expense but our commuter benefits policy helps to offset that.
  • Maternity and Paternity Leave. Mothers are given up to 12 weeks paid time off post birth/adoption. Fathers can choose to take up to 4 weeks paid time off post birth/adoption. We strongly recommend mothers and fathers to take the full time.
  • Adoption Reimbursement. For families who are willing to adopt, thank you! New Story will reimburse eligible team members up to $10,000 for adoption related expenses.
  • Team Summits. Every 6 months we have a full team summit where we have fun, reflect, and plan for the upcoming quarter. Past trips have been in Tahoe, CA and Whidbey Island, WA.
  • Continuing Education. We believe in always learning and leveling up our skills. Whether or not it’s a conference or online course you’ll find we invest in each team member so they can be the best at their craft.
Welcoming Workplace For All

We know we will only succeed if we have a team who brings a wide variety of perspectives and backgrounds. Our team grew up around the world, from Turkey to Chicago to Georgia to Panama, and we welcome all applicants, regardless of background, to apply. We work hard to create a welcoming culture of shared values and radical candor. New Story is an equal opportunity employer. We encourage applicants to apply for employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, disability or genetics.

Join us!

Carve out 20 minutes and apply here.